I saw this on opening weekend and have been mulling over my review of it since then. I have incredibly mixed feelings about the film. But you more of less summed it up for me, albeit a bit less eloquently (i.e. more bluntly) than I would have written.
BLACKKKLANSMAN
2.5/5
For starters, the trailer leads one to believe that the film is going to be a deadpan, satirical look at race relations, perhaps in the vein of classic Coen Bros. films. And while there are moments of that sprinkled throughout the fillm, it's far different than the trailer suggests.
I found the film to be really, really, really uneven and eratic. I chock this up to the fact that there are no less than 4 screenwriters credited with the script. There is no way to tell who wrote what, what was kept from the original script, what was added, etc. Anytime you see more than 3 people with script credits you have to wonder.
The opening of the film seemed pointless as it was never addressed again and the characters in it were never seen again.
I felt that the filmmakers continuously hit the audience over the head with the fact that the film is trying to convey how race relations in the U.S. have not changed since 1970 and that present day "Amerikkka" isn't any better than the years leading up to and following the Civil Rights Movement. This was pretty obvious and implicit and the point didn't need to be continually driven into the minds of the viewers, imho.
There were lots of heavy-handed moments utilizing freeze-frame imagery and close-ups, too.
I had a hard time with the lead actor (Denzel Washington's son) whose character was continuously in "white mode" even though he kept telling his co-workers and superiors that he could code switch on a dime (the scenes where he tries to hook-up with the Black Student Union leader are awkward and show us that he's not able to move between the two worlds of white and black seamlessly; perhaps this was intentional?). In terms of the rest of the cast, Adam Driver seemed to be underutilized and Topher Grace was a bit over-the-top (as were pretty much all of the neo-Nazi Klansmen in the film), but then hyperbole is one of the key rhetorical tenents///
On the positive side there were some great comedic moments, some poignant moments, and some intense moments, but overall I never felt like the film got a solid footing or struck a cohesive balance between biting social commentary and outright satire.
The ending, too, felt forced, as if we hadn't gotten the point yet and needed to be further smacked upside the head.
I did dig the classic floating camera dolly shot at the end and really wished that Lee had inserted more cool visual nuances such as that throughout the film.
Again, perhaps all this was intentional on Lee's part, to create a film that is so polarizing that it leaves you thinking about it long afterwards, even if you didn't like it. And, more importantly, sparks discussion/debate.
Is it one of Lee's best? No. But it's still an interesting experiment.
It does make me want to go back and re-visit Do The Right Thing, though, a film I really loved and moved me very much when I saw it upon first release.
Additionally, I am now somewhat interested in checking out the source material (the autobiography/memoir Black Klansman by Ron Stallwarth)...
Addendum:
In terms of the 3 major films out right now that are written and directed by black filmmakers and that deal specifically with race relations, my "two thumbs up" recommendation goes to Blindspotting. That film is intense, topical, funny, dramatic, poignant, and it unfolds with great pacing, plus it manages to strike an even balance between satire and serious socio-political commentary. Go see that if you canl
Bookmarks