Here’s how you get more than 100% shares. I borrow a share to short sell to someone else. Now two people “own” one share. It’s not that unusual or illegal. It’s just risky.
That's the thing. The 'hedge' on this is that the risk is so massively distributed that it is basically negated. The short selling bag holders have virtually unlimited risk/exposure while the reddit/robinhood crowd threw $250 in a trading account, and most people would be willing to lose that for the lulz alone. Some dude who bought a single share (or even a fraction of one) for $100 doesn't lose his shirt on this kind of market movement - his exposure is what he put in. As opposed to a fund short half a million shares that they have borrowed, sold and need to buy back. They were hoping to be able to buy it back for $5/share and they could end up having to pay $500 a share. Too bad, so sad.
RH is just another broker dealer and a small one at that. The outrage is amusing. If you want to play high stakes game you should be with a BD that can back you up. A BD has no obligation to make a market for anyone. They can suspend any account they want.
RH had no moral high ground. Their only goal was to activate millennial traders.
Wow, it is indeed legal. https://www.fool.com/investing/2021/...ver-100-heres/
It's still royally fucked.
Also seems like incredible risk given the information is publicly available. In the Information Age it seems like walking around with a sticky note that says "mug me".
Option trading is just as or more responsible for this type conundrum.
I would argue short selling and options trades all add liquidity to a market.
Sent from my iPhone using TGR Forums
People who short stocks and do other kinds of questionable financial transactions--remember credit default swaps?- like to trot out the same arguments about liquidity, about driving bad companies out of the markets, about protecting little investors--without ever quite explaining how that works. It's all just naked greed--figuring out ways to take other people's money without doing anything useful. When you're tied up in that world it's hard to appreciate what it is you're doing, but those of us on the outside see.
The original r/WSB people in on this thing from the beginning are likely smart enough to be already out and quadrupled their money.
All the people who read the national news and jumped in during the last two/three days are going to be left holding the bag when the price normalizes.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Best Skier on the Mountain
Self-Certified
1992 - 2012
Squaw Valley, USA
All it will take is for the funds that hold GME to sell. Fidelity owns 10mm shares. a lot of that has to be in discretionary funds.
Top 10 Owners of GameStop Corp
Stockholder Stake Shares owned
Fidelity Management & Research Co... 13.67% 9,534,090
BlackRock Fund Advisors 11.32% 7,897,907
The Vanguard Group, Inc. 7.43% 5,185,112
Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP 6.27% 4,376,045
This quagmire can also be correlated to indexing. If the major holders of stock can't sell due to index fund requirements. If all equity is indexed there is no mechanism for price discovery.
When I worked at the 'O' our bat shit crazy CEO always bitched about naked short selling. Guess he was right.
![]()
When life gives you haters, make haterade.
Bookmarks