Magette Roadies? Saddle fit question

[Cornholio]

My GF is having a hard time finding a saddle that's comfy yet still performance oriented. She's tried solid and "vulva valley" saddles, seems to prefer the valley, but the one she has now just plain sucks.

I know saddle fit is pretty personal, but I thought someone might be able to offer some suggestions.

(Could this thread have been called "Paging Kellie?")

[Monique]

I swear by my Selle San Marco Era saddles for both road and mtb. The saddle doesn't have a "valley" but it's a narrower profile than most saddles so you end up sitting on your...er..."sit bones" where you belong instead of on those sensitive naughty bits.

[Cornholio]

...so you end up sitting on your...er..."sit bones" where you belong instead of on those sensitive naughty bits.

I'm pretty sure this is the problem. I got tipped off to this last week when we were riding and she said, "I feel like I'm sitting on my clit." It was subtle, but I picked it up.

[scoober]

I am not a girl, nor do I play one on TV, but people of all sorts seem to like the newest Specialized BG saddles. You go in and sit on a foam measuring thing that leaves imprints of your sit bones, then you can measure what width saddle to get.

[El Chupacabra]

Fiance says go with the Terry Butterfly; swears it's the most comfortable saddle she's ever used.

If you get the chro-mo railed one, the rails have printed on them that they're made from "FECALLOY." (Should've been a space between FEC and alloy...)

[skiguide]

she said, "I feel like I'm sitting on my clit."

shoot, wouldn't that actually make riding more FUN?

SB is all about me getting one of those specialized custom fit saddles-and after 2 days in a row last weekend, I decided I'll definitely need to do something to avoid those sore butt bones...if i ever get a bike




ok, ok, when I eventually get a bike.

[phUnk]

I'm changing my forums Profile right now.

Location: Vulva Valley

[Monique]

I'm pretty sure this is the problem. I got tipped off to this last week when we were riding and she said, "I feel like I'm sitting on my clit." It was subtle, but I picked it up.

Good. Now just make sure you pick up on any sentence beginning with "I feel like..." and ending with "...my clit." and she's yours forever.

[Camilo]

Selle LDY saddle
My girlfriend, sister in law, and mom's friend all have them and love them. They all got them after complaining about soreness, never complained again after getting the new ones.

[AfroMullet]

Check out Terry or Specialized.

girl I ride with has had good luck with both.

[Kellie]

Wish I could help here - as it turns out "paging Kellie" is a bad name for this because I tend to make whatever I have work. My past bike was so uncomfortable that the seat was the least of my problems . . . so far, the standard seat on the Madone seems to be working fine. Perhaps things will change as I up the mileage

[Vinman]

Mrs V likes the terry butterfly as well

[altagirl]

Wish I could help here - as it turns out "paging Kellie" is a bad name for this because I tend to make whatever I have work. My past bike was so uncomfortable that the seat was the least of my problems . . . so far, the standard seat on the Madone seems to be working fine. Perhaps things will change as I up the mileage

I'm the same way. I've been using the WTB that came on my Yeti forever... I typically think I need to ride more and I'll be fine - it does match up with my sit bones, but I've been riding 6 days a week lately and my butt still hurts, so it's probably time to try something else...

[snow_slider]

Second the Terry Butterfly. My wife loves it.

[boobookitty]

I swear by my Selle San Marco Era saddles for both road and mtb. The saddle doesn't have a "valley" but it's a narrower profile than most saddles so you end up sitting on your...er..."sit bones" where you belong instead of on those sensitive naughty bits.

Word. I'm with you in the less-is-more opinion. I LOVE my Selle Italia Flite saddles. The Trans Am is rad, but it seems like they're all gel flow crap now. My fav. is the straight leather one. I HATE the Terry stuff. They're all way too big, get in the way if your on your mtb. bike, and far too squishy.

Yes, I perfer to sit on something hard.

[altagirl]

Word. I'm with you in the less-is-more opinion. I LOVE my Selle Italia Flite saddles. The Trans Am is rad, but it seems like they're all gel flow crap now. My fav. is the straight leather one. I HATE the Terry stuff. They're all way too big, get in the way if your on your mtb. bike, and far too squishy.

Yes, I perfer to sit on something hard.

Ditto - I tried a terry saddle once and hated it too. Not only is too squishy bad, but too wide is worse - you can't maneuver easily for descents. My saddle now isn't perfect, but I've tried a few that were horrible. Whatever my new saddle is, it's going to be less squishy than the one that's on there now - I think that's the problem.

[girlski0912]

Big fan of the Specialized Telluride. It isn't a gender specific seat, but still has the "clit slit" and is low profile enough to position your body weight on your sit bones. For some reason, certain designs assume that just because women have hips, they are big therefore the saddles need more width to support said hips. This can make that clit pressure thing more prevelant.