Need some reel help - 4wt Click and Pawl
Collective,
I was hoping someone could help me with picking a new reel. It is for my Scott G2 8'8" 4wt. The rod is 2.7 oz....so it is pretty darn light. I currently have a Hatch 3+ on it, which feels a little heavy for my liking. It is a great reel and has not seen many days on the water, but feels a little large and heavy for this rod.
I have a click and pawl on my Scott fiberglass 3wt that I really enjoy fishing. The rod does not have the backbone to turn a larger fish, which it is obviously not intended for, but due to lending out my other rods, I had to fish it one day last summer on the South Platte. I hooked into some pretty large fish and really enjoyed playing them with that reel and hearing it sing.
I want some of this soul for on my 4wt. Does anyone have any suggestions or thoughts on a good click and pawl reel for it? I do have a couple questions about it as well.
- is it true that the click and pawl reels don't start up as smoothly and you can loose some fish on fine tippets?
- should I keep the Hatch for these occations or when I am going to get into some very large trout, or do I sell it cheap to a mag to finance the new reel?
Current reels up for consideration are an Able Trout 2; Red Truck Diesel/Leland Classic Spring Creek. The thing that concerns me about the Red Truck/Leland is it is the same size as their Emerger model, which is what I have on the three weight and it seems like it would be hard to get sufficient backing and the line as it is really small...so I am leaning toward the Abel, but am open to any suggestions.
Am I wrong to want to fish this old style reel when I am targeting trout in the 18" to 22" range?
Thank you...can't wait to go fishing...January snow has sucked in the Front Range!
"We had nice 3 days in your autonomous mountain realm last weekend." - Tom from Austria (the Rax ski guy)
Bookmarks