We recently bought a 2012 Kia Soul 6spd with the 1.6L direct injection motor and Mrs. Cruiser is averaging over 37mpg on her mostly city commute between Littleton and Lakewood and has had a couple of tanks where she got an average of more like 39mpg out of it.
By comparison my '02 Excursion diesel auto is averaging 15mpg around town. And my '08 Xterra 6spd gets about 18.5 in mixed driving.
So, what are you in and how's your real world mileage?