Originally Posted by
Ottime
NY is mostly beach break, but you do get some reefs and points out at the tip. And block island is a ferry ride away. Some nice sand bottom set ups in Rockaway, Queens. On the subway line in case you want city life.
Maine is way quieter. No so cold until January. Some nice juice at a few winter spots. Plenty rippable. All sorts of waves and set ups. Outside the river mouth, there are rarely crowds.
Neither have the perfect juices barrel of the outer banks, but NY is closer. ME waves can be thicker though, but due to the variety, only some breaks are hollow.