The courts decision is plain wrong. In order to read it the way the court read it there would need to be an "or" before packing.
Yep.
Printable View
Huh?
“Maine law exempts overtime requirements for employees engaged in “the canning, processing, preserving, freezing, drying, marketing, storing, packing for shipment or distribution of: produce, meat and fish producers, and perishable foods.” The absence of a comma after “shipment” means “distribution” refers back to “packing” and therefore employees engaged in distribution aren’t exempted from overtime, the First Circuit concluded.”
I generally take judges at their word on language issues but I definitely defer to the first circuit on grammar.
Sent from my iPhone using TGR Forums
Someone had to say it. Thanks
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P_i1xk07o4g
The court is correct.
Oxford commas matter.
the Oxford comma is stylistic--some organizations and publications use it, some--like the AP-don't. https://www.grammarly.com/blog/what-...much-about-it/ Personally I was raised to use it. The only place it is mandatory is where it's presence or absence changes the meaning. In the case in question the lack of "or" in front of packing means that the sentence as written in unambiguous. Adding an Oxford comma would certainly make the sentence easier to read but wouldn't change the meaning.
I suspect that the judge, like many of you, was taught by a dogmatic teacher who beat you or at least took points off if you failed to use the Oxford comma. Or maybe the judge, in a bout of Solomonic wisdom, used fallacious grammatical reasoning to get around a bad law in the interest of justice.
I like that we can have highbrow linguistic discussions in the same forums where people don't punctuate at all or know the difference between there, their and they're. It demonstrates the reach this place has.
howdoyoufeelaboutspacesbetweenwordspersonallytheya nnoymewasteofspaceinmynotthathumbleopinion
btwthatspaceinthemiddleofannoyissomeglitchthatpops upwhenIsubmitmypostwhichisannoyingandltlookslikeit happenedinthissentencetooiguessthatmeansthatthespa ceautomaticallyappearsaftersomanycharacters
I still like two spaces after a period.
https://www.cultofpedagogy.com/two-spaces-after-period/
I learned something to day. (And forgot 4 things.)
Attachment 382020
1987