Do you detune? Why or why not?
I have $thirtyseven if a ski off ensues.
Sent from my iPhone using TGR Forums
Do you detune? Why or why not?
Quote:
Originally Posted by TAFKALVS;
Maybe try detuning a little and see? And if it doesn’t work, sharpen the edges?
Do you suppose, after all this, I yearn for the effortless release of a detuned ski and just have no idea how to achieve such zen? Also, what I said there was to work on stronger edging for the rest of it to maybe make sense.
The point isn’t really what I do or you do, it’s why and what drives the preference. We’ve got some good thoughts in here. I learned some stuff, at least.
Do you detune? Why or why not?
I’d hate for you to slide off the machine made snow in to a cow pasture, so maybe I let you win.
Do you detune? Why or why not?
As a data point, I’ve been skiing some new skis straight from the wrapper mostly out of laziness but given this thread I decided to resist the urge to detune just to see if I was missing something. I’ve gotten 4 days on them now, and feel I can report my findings.
Please note these feelings are subtle and we’re talking about small differences. I have skied “railed” or edge high skis and these feelings I’m describing are magnified 10 - 20x on a ski in that condition.
Ski: 190 Mfree112
Conditions:
Day 1: 5” low density pow over soft base. soft groomers. 27 degree temps
Day 2: 12” high density wind effected upside down snow over very hard icy non-grippy rain crust. 32 degree temps.
Day 3: 2-4” wind blown storm snow over moderate firm but grippy base.
29 degree temps.
Day 4: 6 - 12” medium density pow
over moderate firm but grippy base. 30 degree temps.
Day 1: ski felt grippy on groomers. Occasionally it felt like the tip or tail wanted to engage on a different path than underfoot especially on the uphill ski. off piste the edges released predictably unless I punched through to the base below. In that case the ski wanted to follow its sidecut.
Day 2: Extra pressure was required when making rotary movements to get the ski to release. When in a sideways drift if you found bottom sometimes the ski would “catch”, sometimes not. The underfoot sensation of this I would describe going from slicing tofu with a knife to dragging nails on a chalkboard.
Day 3: when getting off the surf and punching through to the grippy firm snow below, it was a similar sensation - nice drifty turn and then quick catch/hookup on the firm snow below. Nothing unmanageable but had to pay attention and compensate with edge pressure accordingly.
Day 4: medium body snow and high speed skiing in chop. When charging down the fall line and encountering pockets alternating between soft and scraped, a similar sensation of drift to catch (tofu to chalkboard) feeling occurred. Also another time after pointing off a 5-10’ high cliff section on a 40 degree slope in to a steep choppy runout when putting the ski sideways to dump speed on the exit I could feel the edge catch and release. Nothing I couldn’t overcome but not the clean drift the ski is capable of in non-mixed surfaces. Did have one scary moment when I got biased to the uphill inside ski after hitting an unforeseen bump in the fog while skiing fast (welcome to Schweitzer), the tip engaged and had the ski run away a little bit due to sharp edges on grippy firm snow. Was able to reset my weight downhill and get back on track but I don’t think this would have happened if the tip had been detuned.
Summary:
1.) detuning is less about having a particular feel in consistent snow conditions and more about dulling the feedback as snow conditions change turn to turn especially at speed.
2. why you would want the ski to grab on hard snow underneath soft snow I have no idea.
3.) loose edges are less work and more fun for ME in mixed resort conditions when skiing fast.
4.) probably a different thing if you ski slower and just sorta do short swing bounce turns or something.
YMMV