Originally Posted by
PB
Whoa whoa WHOA
How DARE you compare Ghost in the Shell to Alita?!?!?!? :fmicon:
Seriously, the central plot line in GitS (Anime - the live-action, Scarlet version was execrable ) was sophisticated and delivered with subtlety and nuance. Since there wasn't a full length animated version of Alita it's perhaps unfair to compare the two, but you stated that the current live-action version was remarkably close to the original Manga presentation, so I'm going to do it any way: apples vs oranges , mature sophisticated plot vs YA plot. Not a really big deal, as most (but fortunately not all) Manga stories are YA with a titillating frizz of mayhem and sex anyway.