mntlon, I would say (first) seek out whatever 2004 Subis that you can find, especially the Outback, since they just redesigned it. (second) Look for a low mileage Subi just coming off lease. You can pretty much count on trouble free 120000 out of an Outback or Forester.
I've owned Subarus for 10 years, and they absolutely rule. It's all about clearance. I intensely covet a Mini, but stop myself by imagining what it would be like navigating the Bear mountain parking lot at KMart after 12" in the spring and it melted in that little thing.