Originally Posted by
Leavenworth Skier
Aaron, what do you plan on hunting with it and where? I am assuming you don't plan on shooting an animal past 300 or 400 yards? (basing that on the terrain and vegetation we have around here.)
The three that are available at a reasonable cost - Savage 10/110, Tikka T3 and the Remington 700.
If I were you I'd get anyone of those 3 guns in .260 Remington or 7mm-08. Both those rounds are low recoil, good ballistics, good barrel life, relatively cheap to buy ammo and should serve you well. If you want a little more umph, .270 or 30.06 are good rounds with lots of factory hunting loads. All those rifles are going to shoot 1 moa or less at 100 yards.
The .260 and 7mm-08 are both derived from a necked down .308 cartridge, just with a smaller more efficient bullet. 30 cal bullets at 308 velocities kind of suck compared to a .260/6.5 or 7mm.
270 is a great hunting round. It's main drawback is lack of bullets for reloading with long range shooting in mind but for your purposes, you can be almost assured that every store in town will have something in stock for it. Recoil is harsher than the .260 or 7mm-08.
I personally don't like the WSMs, the barrel life is low and the muzzle blast is high. Plus the cost of factory ammo is high. With your history of shoulder injuries I would steer clear of any magnum as the recoil impulse from a short or standard magnum could start causing you issues if you spend a decent amount of time behind the gun getting it figured out. Either way, think about a muzzle brake, even in a short action round like the .260 - it will make shooting the gun far more pleasant.