20mm in Titan Ultralight shell too much?
I have a new pair of Titan Ultralights, and I'm trying to decide if I should go through the time and expense of a full on boot fitting with what may be a borderline shell fit. Unfortunately, I live in an AT equipment desert, and ordered them without being able to try them on. I usually wear a 26, so that's what I ordered. They have a little more room behind my heel bone than I am used to starting with (19-20 mm on one foot, 20-21 mm on the other). I don't know that a 25 is available from the source where I was lucky enough to have a hookup, or that if I will have the luxury of traveling to an area where I might find a 25 to try on before I need to mount my swap plates on a boot center for *something*, and I was hoping it would be these.
The reason I went with the Titan Ultralight was so that I could travel with a single pair of boots. The idea is that these will become a quiver of one for me full time, assuming I can live with the compromises. My current alpine boots need to be unbuckled after most runs. I don't want to have a ridiculously sloppy fit, but also wouldn't complain if I could leave my boots buckled for most of the day. As I'm getting older, my brain is telling me that I might be kidding myself that I need a super precise performance fit, especially on boots that will be used on 5-10 backcountry days throughout the season. But this might be a rationalization since these are here in front of me, and my prospects for knowing if the next size down would be a better fit are slim to none in the short term.
Trying on the boots, they feel fairly good, although with my custom footbeds in it feels like they may need to be widened at the metatarsal / toe joint. Baking the liners might fix this. So, WWMD? I could be over-thinking this, and this shell fit could be fine for a mixed AT and resort boot. Or I could be embarking on expensive mods to expensive boots and never be happy with the result.