Tell me about your minivan

[kathleenturneroverdrive]

I know. I know. Minivans. But first, they're way better than 3 row SUV's, and if you disagree you're wrong. And second, my wife wants one for her car due to work/kid needs so I really have no say in this matter. So I've convinced myself my first point is correct

We currently have an old AWD Sienna that's due for replacement. I figured I'd just get one of those again (likely something used from 2016 - 2020) but the price jump for those over the competition has me looking elsewhere. Especially when snow tires on a FWD van would likely perform as well as an AWD Sienna.

Does anyone have experience with Odysseys or Pacificas from that era? Any major issues to look out for?

[concretejungle]

My partner has a 2015 (I think, I'll check later) Odyssey and it's great. I don't think she's had any issues. It's a tank in the snow with snow tires. The only issues I've had is that the clearance isn't great, it's kind of long and low for manuevering on any 4wd road with large rocks but does great on most any other "off-roading."

[doebedoe]

I have a FWD Sienna with Snows. And AWD with snows is still noticeably better. I carry chains just in case (but haven't really needed them).

My sister has an Odyssey (2016ish) with 180k. Minimal issues. Certainly nicer features than my 2013 Sienna. But that's mostly a matter of spec.

Honestly, the used market is still so fucked that going new makes some sense. Neighbor got an '22 Sienna woodlands edition. It's very nice -- plus 35mpg in a minivan is pretty dope.

[smartyiak]

I love minivans. Not on your list, but the ex and I had a KIA Sorento (until she blew it up). It was FANTASTIC. My favorite car ever and, like you wrote: 1000x better than the SUV it replaced. I guess it was replaced by the Carnival (which also seemed nice), but I really miss the Sorento: tons of room, tons of versatility, but still drove decently and OK mileage.

(Note: bad motor was not Kia issue, but a "spouse not taking it in for servicing despite service intervals and repeated requests to do so" issue).

[Marshall Tucker]

We've always had older Suburbans (i know she has yer balls in a vice but possibly worth arguing some. well, probably not). Those things are fuckin tanks, go anywhere and they laugh there asses off at the stuck Sciennas and oddessys that can't catch thier breath going 5 MPH up the hill. Plus, they'll pull the shit outta anything that needs pullin, AND they are cheep. relatively speaking. ($30k buys a whole lotta gas). AND they still have plenty cargo space with the third row. You absolutely cannot overload it, and if somehow you do, see the pullin part already mentioned.

(BTW I'm a big fan of BTO AND romacin the stone, that user name is HOF material. Arn't thier some cover bands with that name?)

[doebedoe]

My partner has a 2015 (I think, I'll check later) Odyssey and it's great. I don't think she's had any issues. It's a tank in the snow with snow tires. The only issues I've had is that the clearance isn't great, it's kind of long and low for manuevering on any 4wd road with large rocks but does great on most any other "off-roading."

FWIW, relatively simple to put a small lift on the Odyssey (or Sienna, or Pacifica) for extra clearance: https://www.journeysoffroad.com/

I've got 40k on my lifted Sienna with no issues related to the lift except a loss of about 1mpg. Still drives like a minivan. But I don't worry about going up to higher-clearance trailheads. With lift + 1" larger AT tires I've got 10" of clearance.

[Todd Zander]

I have a FWD Sienna with Snows. And AWD with snows is still noticeably better. I carry chains just in case (but haven't really needed them).

My sister has an Odyssey (2016ish) with 180k. Minimal issues. Certainly nicer features than my 2013 Sienna. But that's mostly a matter of spec.

Honestly, the used market is still so fucked that going new makes some sense. Neighbor got an '22 Sienna woodlands edition. It's very nice -- plus 35mpg in a minivan is pretty dope.

What gets 35mpg? Certainly not our ‘17 AWD sienna

Hey look at me, i forgot to shut my mouth and google sienna woodlands edition, cool!

[plugboots]

Tell me about your minivan

What gets 35mpg? Certainly not our ‘17 AWD sienna

The new Sienna hybrid.

I think this is a question of if you need AWD or not. We had a 2005 Odyssey w/studded snows, and it still struggled up snowy/icy hills, (front wheel drive and all the weight in the back). If you need AWD, then it is a Sienna or the new Pacifica, otherwise take your pick. Sienna and Odyssey match each other $/$ and option/option, and probably the same w/ the others, but maybe not as reliable, since there just aren’t as many Kia’s or whatever’s out there.

[doebedoe]

Oh -- and sliding doors kick ass. For kids. For camping. Whatever. Plus most minivans can fit a 8' sheet of ply if you need to haul them.

[Danno]

I have always been a fan of minivans. The big downside, in some ways only downside for me, is lack of clearance/ability to go wheeling.

That said, the notion that a FWD with snows is fine only holds true until you're stuck. After my first winter in real snow country, I committed to never owning a FWD again. There is only so much you can make up for with solid driving skills and snow tires.

[kathleenturneroverdrive]

Thanks all! I'll def check out the Kia too. Sounds like full-on studded tires might make sense + a lift kit is intriguing.

We've always had older Suburbans (i know she has yer balls in a vice but possibly worth arguing some. well, probably not). Those things are fuckin tanks, go anywhere and they laugh there asses off at the stuck Sciennas and oddessys that can't catch thier breath going 5 MPH up the hill. Plus, they'll pull the shit outta anything that needs pullin, AND they are cheep. relatively speaking. ($30k buys a whole lotta gas). AND they still have plenty cargo space with the third row. You absolutely cannot overload it, and if somehow you do, see the pullin part already mentioned.

(BTW I'm a big fan of BTO AND romacin the stone, that user name is HOF material. Arn't thier some cover bands with that name?)

Totally agree on SUV's, but I likely won't drive this one much and I have a truck that I drive. I also have a stupidly short garage so I can likely squeeze a ski rack onto a minivan, but not on a taller Suburban.

And I totally stole my username from Jack Black's fake band in High Fidelity. I think that might actually be the name of a real cover band now too.

Honestly, the used market is still so fucked that going new makes some sense. Neighbor got an '22 Sienna woodlands edition. It's very nice -- plus 35mpg in a minivan is pretty dope.

Agreed on the used market being a kick in the balls right now. We're debating going new, but it's so hard to stomach spending more for something shiny and new and then watching our 3 kids grind banana peels into the seats, lean skis on/scratch the crap out of the exterior, etc.

[TNKen]

Just bit the bullet and get you one of those monster "homeschooler" vans. Nissan NV, Ford Transit, etc.

[toast2266]

We were in the mini van market last year. Need AWD for our shitty driveway. We were all set to get a used Sienna, but the prices people were asking were completely ridiculous so we paid a few grand more and got a new AWD hybrid Sienna.

Upsides:
-Great mileage. high 30's in the summer, low 30's in the winter.
-Fits a spare tire - no more dealing with stupid run-flats.
-It's still a Sienna; well put together, and boatloads of room in there.
-The hybrid drives well. It's not a sports car, but it definitely doesn't feel underpowered.

Downsides:
-It's heavy. The batteries add some noticeable heft to the ass end. It needs to go pretty slow over speed bumps to not bottom out (which is made worse by the receiver hitch I put on the back).
-sounds system is underwhelming.
-There are some electrical quirks that I find annoying. The back up sensors really dislike having a bike rack on the back.

[riser4]

So as an owner of a 2010 FWD Sienna, I avoid driving in situations where I truly need AWD. Otherwise, I just cope. I run good snows. I very much enjoy it for what it is.

[skaredshtles]

So as an owner of a 2010 FWD Sienna, I avoid driving in situations where I truly need AWD. Otherwise, I just cope. I run good snows. I very much enjoy it for what it is.

We still have our '01 Odyssey and it does fine with snow tires in pretty much all situations short of "wheeling" - although there was that one time that we used it to pull a Ford Expedition out of a ditch when we were "wheeling" to get a Xmas tree in Winter Park.