The Official Argue About Where Upstate NY Is Thread

[concretejungle]

Here ya go.

[BmillsSkier]

No, no. It's much more fun to sprinkle this discussion throughout unrelated threads.

Although it does not help to establish a defined area.

[huckbucket]

Listen up assholes. Stay out of western NYS. That means anywhere past the Orange Dome. We like it quiet over here.

[Benny Profane]

It's easy. Anywhere north of commutable distance to NYC.

[hatchgreenchile]

I-84 is the cutoff

[ncskier]

It's easy. Anywhere north of commutable distance to NYC.

What do you define as a commute? I mean in 1.5 hours and a cheap flight, pre-covid I worked in NYC all the time and returned the same day. Many times beating my co-workers home who lived in LI and NJ. Does this mean your theory of NYC extends the entirety of the eastern seaboard is correct?

[BmillsSkier]

Benny, you know we can't take your input seriously since you include Washington DC as part of the NYC metro, right?

Maybe you could help us nail down the headwaters of the Genny Cream?

[ex-powderbroker]

anything north of white plains is upstate.

[Timberridge]

anything north of white plains is upstate.

Honestly, you're the first to go this far south.

[ötzi]

Yeah I think you at least gotta get out of Westchester before you're Upstate,

[ex-powderbroker]

Honestly, you're the first to go this far south.

I don't make the rules, it's just geography.

[Benny Profane]

What do you define as a commute? I mean in 1.5 hours and a cheap flight, pre-covid I worked in NYC all the time and returned the same day. Many times beating my co-workers home who lived in LI and NJ. Does this mean your theory of NYC extends the entirety of the eastern seaboard is correct?

End of train lines (with a little more distance to drive to stations).

[Timberridge]

I'm with otzi on this.

Is there any other state with this issue?

Btw, how does one do an umlaut on a US keyboard?

[The AD]

110th Street.

[BmillsSkier]

I noticed the owner of Tiz The Law isolated himself Upstate to watch his horse win the Belmont this weekend.

The horse itself is from Hudson, New York which I believe is far enough north to be Upstate.